Chain, chain, chain of foolishness

Almost lost in the non-hubbub over the licensing of GKN yesterday was a glimmer of a notion as to why GKN may have gotten into the licensee club at this time. (Yes, I know, Joe specifically said that GKN approached REFR, but that could mean a lot of things, or nothing at all.)

GKN is, and has been a long-time supplier of glass for passenger windows for Boeing aircraft. This is apparently no different for the 787. But wait, you say, weren't Gentex and PPG supposed to supply the windows? Is there a problem? Have those two quietly gotten the boot as a supplier with GKN, backed by their license of SPD, now replacing them?

That's chain the logic intended to be induced, I think, and such was expressed on the message boards yesterday. But, as just about everyone else on the board simultaneously pointed out... there's just one little problem. GKN's license specifically says -- and, to REFR's credit, the press release does mention this -- they're licensed only to put SPD in armored glass. And I can say without fear of contradiction that the passenger windows on the 787? Not going to be armored glass.

The highly likely truth of the matter is that GKN is and always was supplying the glass for the Boeing 787 windows, but rather than supply it directly to Boeing, they are this time shipping it to Gentex and/or PPG for the application of their electrochromatics. That's simple, straightforward, and therefore certain to be rejected in favor of something far more complex that somehow puts REFR in the driver's seat, by those determined to push that agenda. But that's their problem.

The only question remaining, could it be just a coincidence that REFR would choose to license a company working on a project of which their own technology was recently falsely hyped as being a part? Almost certainly not 100% so, but it's not a lock that this was intended entirely as a subtle ploy. It's at least plausible that they wanted to get SPD somewhere vaguely in the neighborhood of the 787 supply chain, "just in case" the whole Gentex/PPG project blows up, even though there's no evidence of that actually happening.

Bottom line, there now seems to be less here than even I had thought.